Advertising disclosure: This article has no affiliate links. The site’s About / Advertising Disclosure page, dated 13 November 2026, said Honest VPN Guide was not part of any affiliate program. Evidence standards: How We Test.

You are already switching vaults — or buying the first one that is not a browser’s default — and the shortlist keeps collapsing to NordPass and Proton Pass. Often because you already pay Nord or Proton for something else.

This page compares them on official security-model paperwork, advertised features, apps, pricing, and migration caveats, using vendor pages checked on 16 November 2026 (Europe/Amsterdam). We did not invent “broke into my vault” stories, UX scores, or personal anecdotes. We have not run our own install or import tests yet, so those cells stay out of the tables rather than being filled with guesses. Bitwarden, 1Password and Apple’s iCloud Passwords appear only as context; we have no affiliate links for them either.

The same intro-versus-renewal habit that shows up in VPN deals also shows up here. For that pattern on VPN plans, see VPN renewal pricing. If you already live in the Nord or Proton VPN world, the broader tunnel comparison is NordVPN vs Surfshark vs Proton VPN.


Who each product is for

NordPass is a password manager in the Nord Security commercial family. It is a natural shortlist item if you already use a Nord Account for NordVPN or another Nord product and want a vault under the same login. Whether it fits you still depends on the current feature list, the audits the vendor actually publishes, and how a migration goes — not on the brand umbrella alone.

Proton Pass is a password manager in the Proton account world (Mail, VPN, Drive and the rest of that stack). It is a natural shortlist item if Proton’s stated end-to-end encryption and open-source posture, checked below, matter to you, or if you already pay for another Proton plan. Whether it fits you still depends on current free and paid limits, and on how import goes.

Neither paragraph is a trophy. Pick the threat model and account gravity you actually have.


Security model basics

Password managers live or die on encryption design, recovery design, and what the vendor can see when your vault is locked. The notes below are vendor paperwork and official help, dated 16 November 2026. They are not a penetration test and not a security ranking.

NordPass (vendor claims, checked 16 November 2026):

  • The official security page describes a zero-knowledge architecture, local end-to-end encryption before upload, XChaCha20 with Poly1305 (private keys encrypted locally with XChaCha20-Poly1305-IETF), and Argon2id with a 16-byte salt to derive a master key from the master password. The same page says NordPass is hosted on Amazon Web Services, with vault items stored in AWS data centres in the US and the EU.
  • The official NordPass Business whitepaper (version 1.9, last updated 4 September 2026), fetched the same day, uses the same cipher family and describes a zero-knowledge model. It is a Business document. ISO/IEC 27001:2022 and SOC 2 Type 2 wording in that whitepaper is also framed for NordPass Business.
  • Independent audits: the security page says the product undergoes regular internal reviews and independent third-party audits, without naming a current consumer audit PDF or date on that page. A Windows download page and a macOS download page both say the desktop application and browser extension have been independently audited by Cure53, again without a report date or PDF on those pages. The public blog post we opened, NordPass Business independent security audit, is dated 20 October 2021 and describes a Cure53 review of the Business product (21 person-days; 15 issues, one high severity, which the post says was fixed and verified). We do not treat a 2021 Business blog post as a current consumer audit report.
  • Emergency access: official help says only a NordPass Premium user (individual Premium or Family) can give emergency access; the recipient can be any NordPass user, including a Free user. The trusted person can request to see passwords and notes without the master password. The owner can accept or decline within 7 days; if they do nothing, access is granted automatically after 7 days. The article lists desktop apps, Android apps and the web vault as surfaces for this feature.
  • The official password-manager FAQ includes the question “Is NordPass open source?” The text we captured under that heading on 16 November 2026 did not include an answer. We therefore do not call NordPass open source.

Proton Pass (vendor claims, checked 16 November 2026):

  • The official security page says vault data is end-to-end encrypted, that Proton cannot access it, and that all fields — not only the password field — are encrypted. It specifies 256-bit AES-GCM for vault encryption and OpenPGP with Curve25519 to protect vault keys and sharing.
  • Proton states that Proton Pass apps are open source and can be reviewed independently.
  • Independent audits Proton has published: Cure53, May–June 2023, covering mobile apps, browser extensions and the API (the 2023 post says reported issues were resolved except one medium-severity Android limitation, PRO-01-003 WP1). Recurity Labs, January–April 2026, covering browser extensions, mobile and desktop apps and the CLI; Proton’s 12 May 2026 post quotes the firm as finding the overall security posture “well above par,” with no remote exploits or encryption bypasses identified, and says desktop memory-handling issues noted in the report were resolved on retest. Those are Proton’s summaries of the reports, not a substitute for reading the PDFs.
  • Emergency access: official Emergency Access help describes an account-level feature on all paid Proton plans (the pricing comparison marks it as not included on Proton Free). You can name up to five emergency contacts; both you and the contact must have a Proton Mail address. You choose a waiting period (1, 2, 3, 7, 14 or 30 days). Proton notifies you of a request so you can deny it; otherwise access is granted when the wait ends. This is broader than a vault-only share: the help text is about access to the Proton account.

We do not crown a permanent “more secure” winner from brand lore or from this paperwork.


Feature grid

Every cell comes from official vendor pages checked on 16 November 2026. A marketing checkbox is still a vendor claim. Where two official pages disagree, the grid says so instead of picking a slogan.

FeatureNordPassProton Pass
Password importOfficial help lists desktop import from LastPass (CSV), Dashlane (CSV, ZIP), Keeper (CSV, JSON), RoboForm (CSV), 1Password (CSV, 1PUX), KeePass (CSV, XML), KeePassXC (XML, CSV), Bitwarden (CSV, JSON) and Proton Pass (JSON, ZIP), plus a generic spreadsheet option. Android and iOS apps have their own import flows; iOS help says apps that do not support CXP should be imported as CSV via the browser extension. Official help also says NordPass passkeys cannot currently be imported or exported.Official import index lists 1Password, Bitwarden, Dashlane, EnPass, KeePass and KeePassXC, Keeper, LastPass, NordPass, Roboform, Chrome, Firefox, Brave, Microsoft Edge, Safari and Kaspersky.
TOTP / 2FA codesThe consumer plans comparison we captured listed “NordPass Authenticator” as not included on Free and also showed it as not included on the other visible plan columns in that same table. A separate password-manager page advertises a “built-in authenticator” for TOTP codes, without attaching that sentence to a named plan in the text we captured. We do not collapse those two official wordings into a single “Premium includes authenticator” claim.The pricing comparison marks “Integrated 2FA” as not included on Proton Free and included on Pass Plus, Pass Family and Proton Unlimited. Proton’s plan explainer says a free account includes up to three 2FA items, and that after a downgrade to Free only the first three 2FA items (by creation date) still display codes. Paid plans get a built-in authenticator and unlimited 2FA codes. We report both official wordings rather than flattening them.
PasskeysOfficial passkey FAQs describe storing and using passkeys, sharing them like other vault items, and the current inability to import or export NordPass passkeys. The password-manager page says the Free plan puts no limit on the number of passwords, passkeys or personal information stored. We did not capture a per-browser support matrix on the pages opened today.Official pricing page: “Passkeys supported on all devices” / “across all devices,” including on Proton Free.
Secure sharingPlans FAQ: Premium adds password sharing and the ability to switch devices without logging in again. We did not capture a separate “how many people” limit on the pages opened today.Free: share vaults with 2 others; individual item sharing not included. Pass Plus / Family / Unlimited: item sharing included; vault sharing with 10 others (Family: per user account). Paid plans also list secure link sharing.
Breach / alias / email toolsPlans comparison: Password Health and Data Breach Scanner are not included on Free and are included on the paid columns we captured. Email Masking is advertised on official marketing and download pages checked today, but that short plans table had no Email Masking row, so we do not assign it to a plan in this grid.Free: 10 hide-my-email aliases; alerts for weak and reused passwords; Dark Web Monitoring not included. Pass Plus, Pass Family and Unlimited: unlimited aliases, Dark Web Monitoring, and extra alias tools (custom domains, additional mailboxes, send from an alias).
Offline accessOfficial Offline Mode help: you can view and copy existing entries while offline; you cannot edit, delete or add entries. Extra limits can apply for Business users and some extension setups.Not stated as a named “offline mode” on the pricing or download pages we opened today, so we do not claim it.
Emergency accessPremium or Family required to give access; 7-day automatic grant if the owner does not respond; listed on desktop, Android and web vault.Included on paid Proton plans, not on Free; up to five Proton Mail contacts; configurable wait of 1–30 days; account-level access.
Password generatorOfficial Windows and macOS download pages and other marketing pages describe a password generator. The short Free/paid checklist on the plans page did not include a generator row, so we do not mark it as a Free-tier bullet from that table alone.Officially listed on Proton Free and on the paid Pass plans.
Autofill quality (our tests)No test data yet. Official pages advertise autosave and autofill.No test data yet. Official pages advertise autofill.

How to read the grid: if two official NordPass or Proton pages disagree, believe neither slogan until you open the current page yourself. Autofill that fights a bank site is a test note — and we have not written those notes.

One NordPass clash is worth calling out in prose. The plans comparison lists Free as not including “Access on multiple devices.” The same plans FAQ talks about Free offering “automatic sync across devices,” and the password-manager page says you can sync the Free plan across multiple devices. We treat the plans checkbox as the limit, and we flag the wording clash rather than pretending it is settled.


Apps and browser support

SurfaceNordPassProton Pass
Windows / macOS / LinuxOfficial download pages opened today exist for Windows and macOS, including a Windows on ARM versus Intel/AMD note on the Windows page. We did not open a Linux download page in this check, so we do not list Linux as confirmed today.Official download page: Windows, macOS and Linux.
iOS / AndroidOfficial import help covers both the Android and iOS apps.Official download page: iOS and Android.
Browser extensionsOfficial macOS and Windows pages describe a browser extension. We did not open each browser’s store page today, so we do not name Chrome, Firefox, Safari or Edge as confirmed NordPass extension targets in this table.Official download page: Chrome, Safari, Firefox and Edge.
Web vault / otherOfficial emergency-access help refers to a web vault. A command-line client is not something we confirmed on the NordPass pages opened today.Official download page: web app and CLI. Pass Plus and higher also list a CLI on the pricing page (not included on Free).

Setup and “took me 30 seconds” notes from our own installs: none yet. We will not publish timings we did not record.


Pricing: free tier versus paid / family / business

Prices below are what official pages printed on 16 November 2026. We do not convert currencies. Sales tax or VAT may still be added at checkout. NordPass’s plans page says displayed prices do not include VAT. Promo labels move quickly — Proton’s pricing page showed percentage-off labels on this check, and NordPass marketing pages showed a Black Friday offer whose percentage did not load in our text capture (“Get up to Loading off”).

NordPass

Official consumer plans on nordpass.com/plans/ are Free, Premium and Family. Download pages also showed 2-year, 1-year and 1-month plan tabs. Curl could not fetch NordPass marketing pages today (HTTP 403, Cloudflare). The plans-page text we did capture listed features and a 30-day money-back guarantee, but did not include a billed total or a renew-at amount. We therefore do not invent a dollar intro price or a year-2 price.

What official pages did print:

  • Free: no credit card required. The short plans checklist includes autosave and autofill and secure storage, and marks as not included: access on multiple devices, Password Health, Data Breach Scanner, NordPass Authenticator, and file attachments. The password-manager FAQ says the Free plan will remain free of charge and has the same stated security level as Premium, but excludes some extra security features. See the multi-device wording clash above.
  • Premium / Family feature shape: paid columns in the same table include multi-device access, Password Health, Data Breach Scanner and file attachments. Family, per the plans FAQ, is six separate encrypted vaults with Premium features; one vault is the owner’s, and the other five can be given to friends or family. You cannot switch from Premium to Family directly in the self-serve path described there; NordPass says to contact support.
  • “Starting at” figures on the official password-manager FAQ: “You can get NordPass Premium starting at €1.23/month.” Family “can be shared by up to six users.” Business Teams, Business and Enterprise plans “starting at €1.79/month.” Those are starting-at monthly-equivalents, not a first-term invoice and not a renewal price. We did not capture the term length or the renew-at line that sits behind €1.23.
  • Money-back and cancel (personal plans): official help offers a 30-day money-back guarantee for personal account customers, only for the initial purchase. After a renewal, the same article says the plan is no longer eligible under that policy unless local law requires otherwise. Cancelling auto-renewal is done in Nord Account → Billing → Subscriptions → cancel auto-renewal. Store-billed plans are cancelled in those stores. Cancelling auto-renewal is not, by itself, a refund.
  • Business refunds are different: the official business plans FAQ offers a refund within 14 calendar days of the initial Business purchase, which is not the same window as the personal 30-day policy. Business prices were not printed as dollar or euro totals in the text we captured (“Payments are charged in USD”).
  • Nord VPN bundle: the consumer plans FAQ says you can add NordVPN to a security bundle with NordPass when you buy or upgrade on your Nord Account. No bundle price was printed in the text we captured, so we do not invent one.

If you need the exact first invoice, open checkout yourself and save the renew-at line. Silence on a public plans page is not a gift.

Proton Pass

Figures below are USD, as shown on proton.me/pass/pricing on 16 November 2026, on the yearly view we captured.

PlanWhat the pricing page printed on 16 November 2026
Proton Free$0.00/month; no credit card required. Unlimited logins, notes and credit cards; unlimited devices; apps; password generator; 10 hide-my-email aliases; alerts for weak and reused passwords; passkeys on all devices; easy import. Comparison table: 1 GB storage, 1 user, 2 vaults.
Pass PlusLabelled “60% off” on this check. $1.99/month equivalent, billed at $23.88 for the first 12 months, then renews at $35.88 every 12 months. The struck-through monthly figure shown was $4.99. Paid extras include unlimited aliases, built-in 2FA, vault and link sharing, Dark Web Monitoring, file attachments, folders, Emergency Access, alias-domain tools and a CLI. Comparison table: 10 GB storage, 50 vaults, 1 user.
Pass FamilyLabelled “50% off” on this check. $2.79/month equivalent, billed at $33.48 for the first 12 months, then renews at $59.88 every 12 months. The struck-through monthly figure shown was $6.99. Described as everything in Pass Plus for up to 6 users, with 6 Pass Plus accounts and a family admin panel. Comparison table: 50 GB storage, 6 users, 50 vaults per user account.
Proton UnlimitedLabelled “50% off” on this check. $6.49/month equivalent, billed at $77.88 for the first 12 months, then renews at $119.88 every 12 months. The struck-through monthly figure shown was $12.99. Bundle includes Proton Pass, Mail, Calendar, VPN and Drive. Comparison table: 500 GB storage, 1 user, Pass features at the paid level; other Proton apps at premium rather than free features.

The marketing page proton.me/pass showed different Pass Plus and Unlimited figures on the same day: Plus at $2.99/month “billed at $35.88 every 12 months,” and Unlimited at $9.99/month “billed at $119.88 every 12 months,” with a “1 month” label visible in that capture and without a first-year-then-renews split. We treat the dedicated pricing page, which printed both the intro total and the renew-at amount, as the figures for this article, and we flag the product-page difference so we do not hide it.

Money-back: the pricing FAQ says you can try Pass Plus or Proton Unlimited risk free and, if you change your mind, cancel and request a refund within 30 days. That sentence does not name Pass Family. We do not assume Family is covered.


Ecosystem lock-in notes

Nord account family: one commercial gravity well with VPN, Pass and other suite pieces. Convenience is real; so is upsell pressure. A NordPass win is not automatic proof that NordVPN is right for you — and the reverse is also true. The official plans FAQ confirms you can add NordVPN to a bundle at purchase or upgrade; without a printed bundle price, that is only a “bundle exists” note, not value math. For current NordVPN pricing and renewal, see VPN renewal pricing and NordVPN vs Surfshark vs Proton VPN.

Proton account family: Mail, Pass, VPN and Drive can be a coherent privacy stack. It is also centralization: one account recovery story, including the account-level Emergency Access model above, and one vendor relationship. Both are true. Proton Unlimited is the official all-in-one subscription on the pricing page we checked; Pass Plus is the Pass-only paid plan.


Migration pain

Theory says “export, import, done.” Practice is often messier: custom fields, TOTP seeds, attachments, passkeys, shared folders.

We have not run a dated import test of either product, so there is no results table here. Until we have logs, these are the general risks — not scores:

  • Keep an encrypted backup of the export, and delete plaintext CSVs after import.
  • Official NordPass help says NordPass passkeys cannot currently be imported or exported.
  • Re-verify a few critical logins manually, especially anything with a TOTP seed or a passkey.
  • Do not treat a vendor’s “easy import” heading as proof that your particular vault will come across cleanly.

When to pick neither

Honest exits from this binary:

  • Bitwarden — official help documents a self-hosting option (Docker on Linux and Windows), checked 16 November 2026. Mentioned as non-affiliate context only.
  • 1Password — often priced and structured differently, with its own family and travel workflows. Mentioned as non-affiliate context only; we did not re-price 1Password for this article.
  • Apple iCloud Passwords / Keychain — a natural fit for Apple households. Apple’s official iCloud for Windows guide, checked 16 November 2026, says that after you set up iCloud for Windows you can use iCloud Passwords in Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge or Firefox via a browser extension, and manage passwords in the iCloud Passwords app on a Windows computer. Two-factor authentication on the Apple Account is required. Check that this covers every device you actually use before treating it as a Nord/Proton substitute.
  • You needed phishing sense and unique passwords more than a paid SKU this month — start with whatever gets you off reuse fastest, then upgrade deliberately.

How this relates to VPN buying

A VPN and a password manager solve different problems. A tunnel does not stop credential stuffing. A vault does not hide your café DNS queries. For what a VPN actually changes on public Wi‑Fi, see VPN vs no VPN.

Bundle pitches (“add Pass to your VPN plan”) deserve price and renewal math, not vibes. Check whether the Pass plan is included, discounted, or separate — and what it renews at. We will not call “VPN + password manager” a better deal without that math.


FAQ

Which is more secure, NordPass or Proton Pass?

Compare current official encryption docs, audit reports and recovery design, with dates. On 16 November 2026, both vendors describe end-to-end / zero-knowledge designs with different cipher suites (NordPass: XChaCha20-Poly1305 and Argon2id; Proton Pass: AES-GCM and OpenPGP / Curve25519). Proton publishes recent Pass audit write-ups (Cure53 in 2023, Recurity Labs in 2026) and says the apps are open source. NordPass publishes a Business whitepaper and refers to Cure53 audits, but the public Cure53 blog post we opened is from 2021 and is about the Business product. That is not a trophy for either side.

Can I use passkeys yet?

Both vendors advertise passkey support on official pages checked today. Proton’s pricing page says passkeys are supported on all devices, including on the free plan. NordPass documents passkeys in its help centre and says they cannot currently be imported or exported. Per-browser behaviour changes; we have not tested it.

Is the free tier enough?

Sometimes, for a small vault. Official limits differ. Proton Free includes unlimited devices and 10 aliases, but tighter 2FA, sharing, storage and vault counts, and no Dark Web Monitoring or Emergency Access. NordPass Free is advertised as unlimited storage of passwords and passkeys, with the plans table excluding multi-device access, Password Health, Data Breach Scanner, file attachments and the “NordPass Authenticator” row. Read the current plan table, not an old screenshot.

Should I buy Pass because I already bought the VPN?

Only if the vault itself wins. Ecosystem convenience is a factor, not a verdict.

Do you have import test results?

Not yet. This article does not invent them.

Who operates this site?

LiBrAi (eenmanszaak, KvK 42049145) — public brand Honest VPN Guide. About.


Related reading


Last updated: 16 November 2026 (Europe/Amsterdam)

Import notes: no dated import test yet.

Prices checked: 16 November 2026 (Europe/Amsterdam), official vendor pages linked in this article.

Features checked: 16 November 2026 (Europe/Amsterdam).

Operator: LiBrAi (eenmanszaak, KvK 42049145) — public brand Honest VPN Guide.